IWC Question&Answer:
Question by Jackson Skinner
First off, let me say that I side with the Sea Shepherd organization. Of course, I’ll try not to be biased on this topic.
In other topics like this, there are many different arguments. “We hunt for research”, “Whaling is banned”, and the sort. Both of those statements may be true, but only in part. The Japanese whaling fleet, IWC, admits to selling the meat to Japanese markets after their research, and Commercial whaling is banned, but scientific research is completely legal. I believe that both IWC and the Sea Shepherds are working within the law.
Now, the reason the world community is so strict about these laws is because most people believe that Whales are beautiful creatures, and they are. Most species of whale are endangered, and as a part of my religion, I feel a responsibility to protect nature. Of course, I’ve looked on both sides of the issue, and on the IWC website, it says that Japanese want commercial whaling to continue. Is that not true? I understand that Whaling is a part of Japanese culture, and you’d rather not see it die, but everyone else would. The website also said that the Japanese kill whales for research for when Whaling is allowed to continue. (I’m paraphrasing) But who can honestly say that they believe whaling will continue in the future? I can’t. 95% of Japanese people say thay haven’t eaten whale meat in a long time, Rarely eat whale meat, or never eat it. That’s a significant number. Of course, I’d like to see what our Japanese users would like to say.
Now, I can’t see any reason for Japan to continue whaling, but I’m willing to debate about this. My opinion won’t change anything, but I want to have an honest opinion. If you can convince me to change my stance, by all means go ahead. Appeal to my better nature. I just don’t see any reason for Japan to continue whaling.
Answer by Josh M
I’m not really an expert on this but these are my arguments why whaling should be allowed:
Every country kills animals. 1 whale could feed thousands whereas in other countries, whereas 1 chicken would feed only a few people. This means that Japan is killing less animals because of the amount if people a whale would feed.
Whales also provide many other resource such as oil and fat for the food industry.
Many of the fish supplied to the western world is from Japan. If less whales are killed; there would be more fish getting eaten. This means the price of fish would increase and there may even be a shortage.
Other countries are killing people, Japan are only killing whales which (in my opinion) don’t have the same value as a humans.
Muslim (maybe Hindu as well) countries class cows as sacred yet they give they slaughter them until they choke on their own blood. Despite the reputation, the way that the MAJORITY of Japaese whalers kill the whales is more humane than this.
Whaling also brings great benefits to the economy.
Read Full Post »